Today's a big day for St Mary's Church. The Council's planning committee will decide whether or not they can demolish and rebuild the church.
This has become quite a battle with
the church on one side and the
20th Century Society on the other.
The church goers say the 1960s building leaks, the underfloor heating has broken down beyond repair, there is no stair-free access and that the layout doesn't meet their needs. They have looked at various options including extensive repairs works and adaptions, and have concluded that the best thing to do is to start from scratch with a new building.
The 20th Century Society on the other side say that this is a fine example of the work of Potter & Hare architechs. They argue that the building is a distinctive part of the area's landscape, particularly as it is close to many listed 20th century buildings like the Pioneer Health Centre (now flats) and Sasoon House.
Since the plans were originally submitted in mid 2004 there have been failed attempts to get the church listed, the original plans had to be withdrawn due to objections about the new design, and a conservation area was imposed without consultation and then withdrawn.
Hopefully this will finally be resolved tonight. The church has made some changes to their plans and the
council's planning officers are recommending that the planning committee approve the application to build a new church.
I will be speaking in support of the new application. The existing building is very striking and the new design is less exciting, but the new design will provide great space for the worshippers, for a daily nursery and for community groups to meet in. I've been to a carol service in the church and to several meetings in the basement meeting room. The existing building is not fit for purpose. It's cold, damp and inaccessible for many residents. Ultimately I think the benefits of a brand new building designed for the needs of the community outweigh the loss of the exisiting building, which although distinctive, is not considered to be worthy of listing and is not particularly well-loved locally either.